Cafe · Sheepshead Bay
Coffee, pastries and home cooking on Jerome Avenue
A cozy Sheepshead Bay cafe with a diner feel, serving coffee, cakes, syrniki and hot breakfast plates.
A cozy Sheepshead Bay cafe with a diner feel, serving coffee, cakes, syrniki and hot breakfast plates.
Berry cakes and pastries that pair well with coffee.
Syrniki and home fries with dill made to order.
A cozy, familiar room with extra seating.
Coffee Spot Cafe is a neighborhood cafe on Jerome Avenue in Sheepshead Bay. It feels more like a cozy diner than a coffee bar, with a second room added while keeping its original warm atmosphere.
Guests come for coffee alongside cakes and pastries, and for dishes like syrniki served hot and home fries with dill. The cafe is open weekdays 8 am to 6:30 pm and weekends 9 am to 5:30 pm.
Cappuccinos, lattes and brewed coffee.
Fresh desserts from the counter.
Farmer's cheese pancakes served hot.
Home fries with dill and other morning dishes.
“I didn’t expect this cafe to have delicious desserts and/ or pastries. It was busy so staff were all kinda rushing stuff but at least not with a mean attitude. 🍰🩷✨This cake with berries in it was really amazing.”
“A true Brooklyn gem. This was the very first coffee shop I visited back in 2010 — and I’m honestly impressed they didn’t ruin it with unnecessary updates. The atmosphere remains authentic, warm, and timeless.”
“A cozy place with its own atmosphere, more like a diner than a coffee shop, but the coffee here is pretty good. I ordered syrniki, the portion is small, but they look and taste great.”
Coffee Spot Cafe · Sheepshead Bay
Claim this listing free to correct your details, or get featured at the top of Sheepshead Bay.
Claim this listing Feature my business