Bakery and Cake Shop · Midtown
Creative Cookies Near Broadway Theaters
Fresh, soft-centered cookies in Midtown with creative flavors, gluten-free options, and a connection to New York’s theater community.
Fresh, soft-centered cookies in Midtown with creative flavors, gluten-free options, and a connection to New York’s theater community.
Try creative cookies named after Broadway shows, including a Book of Mormon-inspired flavor mentioned by reviewers.
Reviewers describe cookies as fresh, chewy or soft in the middle, with a slight crunch on the outside.
Choose from more than 45 cookie varieties, including gluten-free options and favorites such as Funfetti and classic chocolate chip.
Schmackary's is a bakery and cake shop at 362 W 45th St in Midtown, New York, specializing in cookies with more than 45 varieties, including gluten-free options.
Reviews highlight fresh cookies with soft centers, slight outer crunch, balanced sweetness, and a small touch of salt. Popular mentions include Funfetti, classic chocolate chip, and Broadway-inspired flavors named after shows.
Browse a wide selection of creative cookie flavors inspired by Broadway shows and classic favorites.
Enjoy familiar choices such as chocolate chip, with a soft center and slight outer crunch.
Choose from available gluten-free cookie varieties.
Try cookies connected to the theater community, including flavors named after Broadway shows.
“Schmackarys is a cute little cookie shop in Hell’s Kitchen! I had a wonderful experience. The cookies are super sweet but have a little touch of salt that makes them wonderfully tasty!”
“I stopped by Schmackary’s in NYC and honestly it was one of the best cookie places I’ve ever tried. The cookies are incredibly fresh, soft in the middle, and full of flavor. You can really tell they care about quality ingredients.”
“Somehow NYC has a bunch of competing gourmet cookie chains. Schmackary’s is a delicious offering, with more reasonably sized cookies, which were all named after Broadway shows. I got the Book of Mormon one, which was great.”
Schmackary's · Midtown
Claim this listing free to correct your details, or get featured at the top of Midtown.
Claim this listing Feature my business