Pizza restaurant · Midtown
Classic New York Slices In Midtown
Thin, crisp pizza with meat and vegetable toppings, finger foods, and late-night service near West 41st Street.
Thin, crisp pizza with meat and vegetable toppings, finger foods, and late-night service near West 41st Street.
Reviewers describe the crust as perfectly cooked, crisp, airy, and made for the traditional New York fold.
Choose from pizza with meat or vegetable toppings, including pepperoni, margherita, and pineapple with ham.
Open late on Friday and Saturday, with service extending until 2 am for late-night slices and finger foods.
Carnegie Pizza is a small, humble pizzeria at 200 W 41st St in Midtown, New York. The menu includes New York-style pizza with a variety of meat and vegetable toppings, along with finger foods.
Reviews highlight thin crust with a crisp, airy texture, quality toppings, flavorful sauce, large slices made for folding, quick service, and late-night availability. Seating is limited, but the upbeat storefront makes it easy to stop in, grab a slice, and keep moving through Midtown.
Large, thin-crust slices with a variety of meat and vegetable toppings.
A traditional topping option praised by reviewers for its flavor.
Pizza with sauce that reviewers describe as especially flavorful.
A finger-food option noted by reviewers at the storefront.
A lighter menu option mentioned in customer reviews.
“This spot was close to our hotel and the first true NYC slice we tried and we are glad it was the first! The pizza tasted great. Crust was cooked perfectly and toppings were quality.”
“This place was awesome. We're visiting from the Midwest and I wanted a slice of "New York" pizza. I got pineapple/ham and split the slice with my son (they are BIG).”
“This was really good pizza. We arrive late night. Still plenty of options. New York style. It looked like they had some deep dish New York style garlic knots. They had nice salad. Very happy to have us after midnight small storefront.”
Carnegie Pizza · Midtown
Claim this listing free to correct your details, or get featured at the top of Midtown.
Claim this listing Feature my business