Bakery and Cake Shop · Financial District
Fresh Cookies In The Financial District
Thick, freshly baked cookies in classic and creative flavors from a tiny neighborhood cookie shop on Cedar Street.
Thick, freshly baked cookies in classic and creative flavors from a tiny neighborhood cookie shop on Cedar Street.
Customers mention fresh batches, thick cookies, big chocolate pieces, and a rich sweet-and-savory balance.
Try mini cookies across several flavors or choose a full-sized cookie when you want something more substantial.
Reviewers describe the shop as a tiny, welcoming spot with kind and helpful service.
The Cookie Odyssey is a bakery and cake shop at 35 Cedar St in New York’s Financial District. Its small gazebo-like shop sits outside Pi Bakerie, making it an easy stop for freshly baked cookies.
Choose from mini or full-sized cookies in flavors such as chocolate chip, banana, oats and raisins, pecan, ginger chocolate chip, Cyclops, and Odyssey. Reviews highlight thick cookies, generous chocolate chunks, balanced sweetness, and friendly service.
Thick, generously portioned cookies in rotating and classic flavors.
Smaller cookies that make it easy to sample several flavors in one visit.
Options mentioned by customers include chocolate chip, banana, oats and raisins, pecan, ginger chocolate chip, Cyclops, and Odyssey.
Cookies are available for workplace gatherings and meetings, according to customer reviews.
“Oh my god, that was one of the BEST cookies I’ve ever had. First of all I walked into pi bakerie. I was confused why I didn’t see cookies until I saw the little hut right outside the bakery.”
“Absolutely delicious! Stopped in on a Sunday afternoon. Had no idea this place was just a tiny little gazebo-like building and nearly walked passed it. Woman behind the counter was very nice and friendly.”
“Delicious chocolate chip cookie- one of the best I’ve had in the city. Way better than Smackerys! Perfect mix of sweet with a hint of salt for that rich savory flavor. Plenty of chocolate bits too. 10/10 no notes!”
The Cookie Odyssey · Financial District
Claim this listing free to correct your details, or get featured at the top of Financial District.
Claim this listing Feature my business