This page was created for Butterly Bakeshop by PageNearby · Own it with your own domain and photos for $50
Bakery and Cake Shop · Crown Heights

Fresh Cakes, Cookies, And Cupcakes

A neighborhood bakery in Crown Heights serving soft cookies, thoughtful cakes, cupcakes, and dessert favorites for everyday celebrations.

Get directions
★★★★★ 4.6 from 152 Google reviews
Butterly Bakeshop, Bakery and Cake Shop in Crown Heights
01

Soft, Chewy Cookies

S’mores cookies are noted for fluffy, chewy marshmallow, while the Nutella cookie balances chocolate filling with a salty finish.

02

Fresh Cake Slices

The lemon blueberry cake slice is described as soft and fresh, with lemon buttercream that is pleasant and not overly sweet.

03

Celebration Desserts

Customers order cupcakes for monthly milestones and choose vintage cakes and other desserts for birthdays and surprises.

04

Convenient Crown Heights Location

Find the bakery at 263 Prospect Park W in Brooklyn, serving Crown Heights and nearby neighborhoods.

About

A Sweet Stop In Crown Heights

Butterly Bakeshop is a bakery and cake shop at 263 Prospect Park W in Brooklyn’s Crown Heights neighborhood. The menu includes cookies, cupcakes, cakes, cake slices, and banana pudding.

Reviews mention soft, chewy S’mores cookies, Nutella cookies with a salty finish, lemon blueberry cake with lemon buttercream, and cupcakes enjoyed for monthly family celebrations. The bakery is also described as clean, with excellent service.

Fresh today

What we offer

Cookies

Choose from bakery cookies such as S’mores and Nutella.

Cupcakes

Pick up cupcakes for everyday treats or monthly family celebrations.

Cakes And Cake Slices

Order celebration cakes or enjoy individual slices, including lemon blueberry cake.

Banana Pudding

Add banana pudding to a cupcake order or enjoy it as a separate dessert.

Wedding Bakery

Explore bakery options for wedding and special-event desserts.

Reviews

What people say

“Smores cookies is the best! Took a first bite and I had like a cheese string pull but it was the nice soft fluffy chewy marshmallow My husband had the Nutella cookie it’s a perfect amount of Nutella in my opinion Though some don’t like the…”
★★★★★ · Google review
“Every month since my daughter was born, my husband has gone to Butterfly Bakery to buy a cupcake so we can celebrate her turning another month older.”
★★★★★ · Google review
“I ordered through Grubhub. Someone look at the practical cake box they sent! That alone made me excited to try the Lemon blueberry cake slice; which tasted like a blueberry muffin. So soft and fresh.”
Visit

Find us in Crown Heights

263 Prospect Park W, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States +1 (929) 276-XXXX

Visit The Bakeshop

Butterly Bakeshop · Crown Heights

Is this your business?

Claim this listing free to correct your details, or get featured at the top of Crown Heights.

Claim this listing Feature my business

Get the number

Enter your email and we will show you the phone number for Butterly Bakeshop right away.

Butterly Bakeshop

Call now