Pizza restaurant · New York NY
Fresh New York Slices On Amsterdam Avenue
Classic and creative pizza slices, whole pies, and oven-reheated favorites served in New York, NY.
Classic and creative pizza slices, whole pies, and oven-reheated favorites served in New York, NY.
Slices are reheated in the oven so they arrive hot and fresh.
Choose from classic cheese, veggie, pepperoni, sausage, vodka pizza, deep dish, and other rotating options.
English- and Spanish-speaking staff make ordering comfortable for local families, visitors, and quick stops.
Made In New York Pizza serves pizza at 421 Amsterdam Ave in New York, NY. Guests can stop in for individual slices or full pizzas, with plenty of styles and toppings to choose from.
Reviews mention oven-reheated slices served fresh, vodka pizza, cheese and veggie slices, pepperoni and sausage, and deep dish pieces with generous vegetables. The clean shop also has bilingual English- and Spanish-speaking staff for comfortable ordering.
Choose individual slices including cheese, veggie, pepperoni, sausage, vodka, and other specialty options.
Order full pizzas with a variety of toppings and styles.
Enjoy deep dish slices with generous vegetables and a substantial crust.
Try square pizza options, including slices with cupping pepperoni.
“Very delicious pizza!! I love how everything is presented to you and the fact that they reheat the pizza in the oven so it is fresh out of the oven. I went during an odd time around 3pm so there literally nobody so lucky me!”
“Nice slice, pepperoni and sausage was on point. Lots and lots of options, I didn't get the square pie with the cupping pepperoni but it looked delish. Prices are good, place is clean, lots of pizza options in town but can't go wrong here.”
“We stopped by for some pizza slices one night as we were arriving back at the hotel, and it turned out to be a great choice. The staff is bilingual, speaking both English and Spanish, which makes ordering very easy and comfortable.”
Made In New York Pizza · New York NY
Claim this listing free to correct your details, or get featured at the top of New York NY.
Claim this listing Feature my business