Bakery and Cake Shop · New York NY
Classic Treats, Made For More Tables
Gluten-free, dairy-free, and kosher bakery treats, custom cakes, and familiar favorites served on Broadway in New York.
Gluten-free, dairy-free, and kosher bakery treats, custom cakes, and familiar favorites served on Broadway in New York.
Find familiar American bakery treats made with gluten-free, dairy-free, and kosher options.
The custom cake team helps shape designs to fit birthday parties and other celebrations.
Customers mention lightly sweet linzer tarts, lemon poppy bun cake, cream puffs, and moist cakes.
By the Way Bakery is a bakery and cake shop at 2440 Broadway in New York, NY. The shop offers gluten-free, dairy-free, and kosher versions of classic American treats, including cookies, brownies, cream puffs, mini Bundt cakes, and tarts.
Customers come for thoughtful custom cakes and pastries with balanced sweetness and moist, flavorful texture. Reviews mention lemon cake, lemon poppy bun cake, linzer tarts, chocolate mini Bundt cakes, and friendly help choosing pastries for birthdays and everyday treats.
Personalized cakes for birthdays and celebrations, including lemon cake designs.
Classic bakery treats available in gluten-free and dairy-free versions.
Filled pastries highlighted by customers as a favorite.
Small Bundt cakes in flavors such as chocolate.
Pastries including linzer tarts and lemon poppy bun cake.
“I love By the Way Bakery! I ordered a delicious 9 inch Lemony Lemon cake with a classic brush stroke design for a birthday party and it was a hit.”
“Soo hyped to have found a great gluten free & dairy free bakery. It has classic items like cookies & brownies and more interesting ones like cream puff and mini Bundt cakes. It was reasonably priced too.”
“I can finally have birthday cake again! I'm lactose intolerant and am on a low-fodmap diet! I haven't been able to get birthday cake I can actually eat for several years now! I'm sooooo glad I found you guys!”
By the Way Bakery · New York NY
Claim this listing free to correct your details, or get featured at the top of New York NY.
Claim this listing Feature my business