New York-style pizza in Lexington's Distillery District
Goodfellas Pizzeria on Mill Street serves hefty New York-style slices, calzones, subs and make-your-own pizzas in a casual setting.
Reviewers praise the hand-tossed crust and the way the pizza is cooked.
The pizzeria is open late, with hours extending past midnight on most nights.
Guests describe the staff as kind and helpful, even on busy nights.
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street is at 110 North Mill Street in Lexington, Kentucky, in the Distillery District. The casual pizzeria serves New York-style pizza by the slice and by the pie, plus calzones, sub sandwiches and build-your-own pizzas.
Guests describe hand-tossed dough and a lively atmosphere, and the restaurant keeps late hours, with service running past midnight on several nights. Many visitors come after dinner or a night out, and reviewers describe the staff as kind and helpful.
Hefty slices and whole pies with hand-tossed dough.
Build a pizza with your own choice of toppings.
Filled calzones for dining in or takeout.
Sub sandwiches for lunch or dinner.
Pizza and subs to go.
“If you’re in Lexington, this is a must do and must see. Located in the Distillery District near Old Pepper and Dark Arts — and only about 30 minutes from Buffalo Trace — Goodfellas delivers an experience that’s just as satisfying visually a…”
“Best Pizza ive ever ate, no joke 10 outta 10 💜me and my fiance dropped in and they were super busy, no wonder lol it has no business being that good lol but we got it quickly after ordering. Vibe is on point ☝️”
“Love this place not only for it's food, but also the workers there know how to treat you right. I'd lose my mind dealing with a bunch of annoying college kids coming in late night after the bar, but workers are always kind and helpful.”
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street is at 110 N Mill St, Lexington, KY 40507, United States. Use the map on this page for directions.
Opening hours: Monday 11 am–12 am; Tuesday 11 am–12 am; Wednesday 11 am–12 am; Thursday 11 am–3 am; Friday 11 am–3 am; Saturday 11 am–3 am; Sunday 11 am–12 am.
Yes, Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street is open on Saturday, 11 am–3 am.
Tap "Get the phone number" on this page to see the phone number for Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street and call directly.
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street has a 4.3 out of 5 rating from 1405 Google reviews.
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street lists: New York-style pizza, Make-your-own pizza, Calzones, Sub sandwiches, Takeout. See the full list above.
Yes. Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street is a pizza restaurant in Lexington KY.
Claim this listing free to correct your details, or get featured at the top of Lexington KY.
Claim this listing Feature my business