5 Underrated Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay, New York NY Worth Trying
Updated 29 September 2026 · 9 restaurants in Sheepshead Bay, New York NY considered · Ranked from Google ratings
This guide covers five restaurants in Sheepshead Bay that earn strong Google ratings but have not yet collected a large number of reviews. Only places rated 4.4 or higher with fewer than 400 reviews qualified, and the final order comes from Google ratings weighted by review count. It is meant for locals and visitors who want a solid meal away from the most crowded names. Each entry lists what reviewers mention, along with hours and practical details to help you plan a visit.
#1
Guda Brooklyn
★ 5 (130 Google reviews)Georgian restaurant$30–80 per person
Representative photo, not of this business.
Guda Brooklyn is a Georgian restaurant on Emmons Ave, open daily from noon, until 11 pm on Fridays and Saturdays. Reviewers mention vegetarian-friendly Georgian dishes such as pkhaleuli, green bean salad and Georgian salad with walnuts, plus a balance of traditional and contemporary flavors. They also point to attentive service and a cozy room. Google lists outdoor seating, live music, cocktails, happy-hour food and drinks, late-night food, and full wheelchair access.
Best for: Georgian dinner with live music
- Address
- 2027 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235, United States
- Hours
- Fri 12–11 pm; Mon 12–10 pm; Sat 12–11 pm; Sun 12–10 pm; Thu 12–10 pm; Tue 12–10 pm; Wed 12–10 pm
#2
Sunny House
★ 4.8 (288 Google reviews)Restaurant$20–60 per person
Representative photo, not of this business.
Sunny House on Sheepshead Bay Rd serves Georgian food from 11 am to midnight, and it is closed Tuesdays and Wednesdays. Regulars point to the pkhali platter, lobio for sharing, and mushrooms with potatoes as a side. First-timers say the staff helped them understand the menu, and one Friday visit came with live music. Reviewers also mention using it for birthday gatherings. Google lists wine, small plates, vegetarian options, table service and a kid-friendly setting.
Best for: Trying Georgian food for the first time
- Address
- 1788 Sheepshead Bay Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11235, United States
- Hours
- Fri 11 am–12 am; Mon 11 am–12 am; Sat 11 am–12 am; Sun 11 am–12 am; Thu 11 am–12 am; Tue Closed; Wed Closed
#3
Cento Uno Pizzeria
★ 4.8 (270 Google reviews)Pizza restaurant$1–10 per person
Representative photo, not of this business.
Cento Uno Pizzeria is a counter-service pizza shop on Quentin Rd, open most days from 11 am to 7 pm, with short Friday hours and closed Saturdays. Reviewers mention a feta tomato slice, creamy mushroom and spinach calzones, a veggie gluten-free pizza, and onion rings that are not greasy. They describe fresh, crispy dough and a spotless shop. Google lists outdoor seating, dessert, delivery, and a family-friendly setting suited to groups.
Best for: Calzones and gluten-free pizza
- Address
- 3101 Quentin Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11234, United States
- Hours
- Fri 11 am–3 pm; Mon 11 am–7 pm; Sat Closed; Sun 11 am–7 pm; Thu 11 am–7 pm; Tue 11 am–7 pm; Wed 11 am–7 pm
#4
Surf City Pizzeria 2
★ 4.8 (38 Google reviews)Italian restaurant$10–20 per person
Representative photo, not of this business.
Surf City Pizzeria 2 is a newer Italian spot on 65th St, open 11:30 am to 10 pm every day except Monday. Reviewers mention large pizzas, a wide range of pizzas and pastas, a clean room and a welcoming counter, and several call the prices good. One review found the fries greasy on a delivery order. Google lists brunch, catering, curbside pickup, late-night food, vegetarian options and a casual, family-friendly setting.
Best for: Pizza and pasta for the family
- Address
- 2301 65th St, Brooklyn, NY 11204, United States
- Hours
- Fri 11:30 am–10 pm; Mon Closed; Sat 11:30 am–10 pm; Sun 11:30 am–10 pm; Thu 11:30 am–10 pm; Tue 11:30 am–10 pm; Wed 11:30 am–10 pm
#5
Sweet Pizza, Inc.
★ 4.8 (36 Google reviews)Pizza restaurant$1–10 per person
Representative photo, not of this business.
Sweet Pizza, Inc. is a pizza restaurant on Avenue U, open daily until 10 pm, starting at noon on Sundays. Reviewers mention that the corner has long been a pizzeria and that this shop has built its own identity. They point to a flavorful sauce, fresh pies, good portions, and a shrimp parm that comes with garlic knots. One describes an old neighborhood feel. Google lists curbside pickup, delivery and a kid-friendly, casual setting.
Best for: Neighborhood slice and shrimp parm
- Address
- 207 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11223, United States
- Hours
- Fri 11 am–10 pm; Mon 11 am–10 pm; Sat 11 am–10 pm; Sun 12–10 pm; Thu 11 am–10 pm; Tue 11 am–10 pm; Wed 11 am–10 pm
How we made this list
We looked at 9 restaurants in Sheepshead Bay, New York NY with a Google rating of 4.0 or higher and at least 20 reviews, then rated 4.4 or higher on Google but with fewer than 400 reviews. A rating from thousands of reviews counts for more than the same rating from a handful, so a new place with a few perfect scores does not jump the queue. Ratings and hours are from public Google listings on 29 September 2026 and can change. Nobody paid to be on this list.
Tips before you go
- Guda Brooklyn takes reservations, useful on weekend evenings.
- Hours and prices come from Google listings and change, so check the listing before a long trip.
Frequently asked questions
Which is the highest-rated restaurant on this list?
Guda Brooklyn ranks first, with a Google rating of 5 from 130 reviews. Sunny House is second at 4.8 from 288 reviews.
Which restaurants in Sheepshead Bay, New York NY are open late?
Sunny House stays open until 12 am.
How much does it cost at these restaurants?
Google lists these price ranges per person: Guda Brooklyn $30–80; Sunny House $20–60; Cento Uno Pizzeria $1–10; Surf City Pizzeria 2 $10–20; Sweet Pizza, Inc. $1–10.
Which of these have free parking?
Google lists free parking for Guda Brooklyn, Cento Uno Pizzeria and Surf City Pizzeria 2.
More guides for Sheepshead Bay
Run a business in Sheepshead Bay?
Get a fast website with your hours, menu, location and reviews. If your business is listed here and something is wrong, tell us and we fix it.
Email support@pagenearby.com