5 Underrated Restaurants in Prospect Heights, New York NY Worth Trying
Updated 29 September 2026 · 7 restaurants in Prospect Heights, New York NY considered · Ranked from Google ratings
This guide covers five restaurants in and around Prospect Heights, Brooklyn that score well on Google but still have modest review counts. Each place is rated 4.4 or higher with fewer than 400 reviews, and seven qualifying businesses were considered before ranking by Google rating weighted by review count. It helps residents and visitors who want a solid slice, a sit-down pie or a generous pasta plate, with notes on hours, seating and what reviewers order.
#1
Pizza Party Brooklyn
★ 4.9 (27 Google reviews)Pizza restaurant$10–20 per person
Representative photo, not of this business.
Pizza Party Brooklyn at 625 Bergen St is a pizza restaurant open from Tuesday through Sunday, closed Monday, with late hours on Sunday. Reviewers say the dough and sauces are made in house and point to the spicy pepperoni pie, a ranch dressing they want on everything, crispy risotto hash browns and an apple toast. They note the pizza pairs well with beer and describe a small, welcoming team. It is casual, good for kids and offers catering.
Best for: House-made pies with beer
- Address
- 625 Bergen St, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States
- Hours
- Fri 4–9:30 pm; Mon Closed; Sat 12–9:30 pm; Sun 1 pm–1:30 am; Thu 4–9 pm; Tue 4–9 pm; Wed 4–9 pm
#2
La Flor Pizza
★ 4.8 (322 Google reviews)Pizza restaurant$1–10 per person
Representative photo, not of this business.
La Flor Pizza at 766 Classon Ave is a neighborhood pizzeria open daily from noon, in the lowest listed price band. Reviewers praise a crust that balances crisp and soft, well seasoned sauce, crispy charred pepperoni, a tomato bruschetta pizza and a white pie with honey. One finds the room small and a little dingy, but still rates the pizza highly. It offers outdoor seating, delivery and curbside pickup, and dogs are allowed outside.
Best for: Classic Brooklyn slices
- Address
- 766 Classon Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States
- Hours
- Fri 12–9 pm; Mon 12–9 pm; Sat 12–9 pm; Sun 12–8 pm; Thu 12–9 pm; Tue 12–9 pm; Wed 12–9 pm
#3
Crown Heights Pasta
★ 4.8 (30 Google reviews)Italian restaurant$10–20 per person
Representative photo, not of this business.
Crown Heights Pasta at 565 Lincoln Pl is an Italian restaurant open every day from late morning until 10 pm or later. Reviewers mention generous portions and fair prices, naming rigatoni with pesto and shrimp, chicken alfredo and a chicken parm hero big enough to need two containers. One diner enjoyed the food but reported rude service over a request for tap water. It is casual and cozy, with delivery and takeaway.
Best for: Big pasta plates and heroes
- Address
- 565 Lincoln Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States
- Hours
- Fri 11 am–11:30 pm; Mon 11:30 am–10 pm; Sat 11:30 am–11:30 pm; Sun 11:30 am–10 pm; Thu 11:30 am–10 pm; Tue 11:30 am–10 pm; Wed 11:30 am–10 pm
#4
Supreme pizza NY
★ 4.7 (121 Google reviews)Pizza restaurant$1–10 per person
Representative photo, not of this business.
Supreme pizza NY at 22 4th Ave is a pizza shop open from 9 am until well past midnight most nights, which suits late-night cravings. It sits in the lowest listed price band. Reviewers describe it as a newer spot with crispy crust, good sauce, fresh toppings and quick, friendly service. One notes there are no tables, so plan on takeaway or delivery. Vegetarian and vegan options are listed.
Best for: Late-night slices to go
- Address
- 22 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217, United States
- Hours
- Fri 9 am–12:30 am; Mon 9 am–3 am; Sat 9 am–3:30 am; Sun 9 am–3:30 am; Thu 9 am–3:30 am; Tue 9 am–3 am; Wed 9 am–3:30 am
#5
SIMÒ PIZZA - BROOKLYN
★ 4.5 (99 Google reviews)Pizza restaurant
Representative photo, not of this business.
SIMÒ Pizza at 629 Dean St is open daily from 11 am to 10 pm and serves Neapolitan-style pizza. Reviewers mention good value, a great crust and a prosciutto and funghi pie, along with quick, attentive service and help choosing toppings. One reviewer finds the high-ceilinged modern space a bit sterile but still rates the pizza as very respectable. It has a wheelchair-accessible entrance, seating and restroom.
Best for: Neapolitan pizza lunch
- Address
- 629 Dean St, Brooklyn, NY 11238, United States
- Hours
- daily 11 am–10 pm
How we made this list
We looked at 7 restaurants in Prospect Heights, New York NY with a Google rating of 4.0 or higher and at least 20 reviews, then rated 4.4 or higher on Google but with fewer than 400 reviews. A rating from thousands of reviews counts for more than the same rating from a handful, so a new place with a few perfect scores does not jump the queue. Ratings and hours are from public Google listings on 29 September 2026 and can change. Nobody paid to be on this list.
Tips before you go
- For an early start, Supreme pizza NY opens at 9 am.
- Hours and prices come from Google listings and change, so check the listing before a long trip.
Frequently asked questions
Which is the highest-rated restaurant on this list?
Pizza Party Brooklyn ranks first, with a Google rating of 4.9 from 27 reviews. La Flor Pizza is second at 4.8 from 322 reviews.
Which restaurants in Prospect Heights, New York NY are open late?
Pizza Party Brooklyn stays open until 1:30 am; Supreme pizza NY stays open until 3:30 am.
How much does it cost at these restaurants?
Google lists these price ranges per person: Pizza Party Brooklyn $10–20; La Flor Pizza $1–10; Crown Heights Pasta $10–20; Supreme pizza NY $1–10. The others do not list a price range.
Which of these have free parking?
Google lists free parking for La Flor Pizza.
More guides for Prospect Heights
Run a business in Prospect Heights?
Get a fast website with your hours, menu, location and reviews. If your business is listed here and something is wrong, tell us and we fix it.
Email support@pagenearby.com