5 Best Italian Restaurants in Bensonhurst, New York NY
Updated 28 September 2026 · 7 restaurants in Bensonhurst, New York NY considered · Ranked from Google ratings
This guide highlights five top-rated Italian restaurants in Bensonhurst, New York, selected by Google category and weighted rating from seven qualifying businesses. Whether you seek large-group dining, authentic Sicilian pizza, or casual paninis, this list helps locals and visitors find reliable spots. Each entry reflects specific reviewer feedback on food quality, atmosphere, and amenities, ensuring you know exactly what to expect before visiting.
#1
Mama Rao's
★ 4.7 (763 Google reviews)Italian restaurant
Representative photo, not of this business.
Mama Rao's offers a lively, boisterous atmosphere suitable for groups of ten or wedding parties. Reviewers praise the perfect appetizers, drinks, entrees, and desserts. The menu features fresh food with fair pricing and generous portions. The location includes wheelchair-accessible entrances, seating, and restrooms. Hours run from noon to 10 pm on most days, with Mondays closed.
Best for: Large groups and weddings
- Address
- 6408 11th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11219, United States
- Hours
- Fri 12–10 pm; Mon Closed; Sat 12–10 pm; Sun 12–10 pm; Thu 12–10 pm; Tue 12–10 pm; Wed 12–10 pm
#2
L&B Spumoni Gardens
★ 4.6 (11,580 Google reviews)Italian restaurant
Representative photo, not of this business.
L&B Spumoni Gardens serves authentic Sicilian-style pizza with a crispy crust and rich tomato sauce. Reviewers also highlight the pasta with clams and veal parm. Portions are described as enormous. The spot operates daily from 11 am to 11:30 pm. Facilities include wheelchair-accessible entrances, seating, and toilets. The atmosphere contributes to a memorable dining experience.
Best for: Sicilian pizza and pasta
- Address
- 2725 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11223, United States
- Hours
- daily 11 am–11:30 pm
#3
Panino Rustico of Bensonhurst
★ 4.6 (690 Google reviews)Italian restaurant$10–20 per person
Representative photo, not of this business.
Panino Rustico of Bensonhurst offers a casual spot for breakfast, lunch, and dinner with prices ranging from $10 to $20. The menu features a wide variety of paninis, wraps, savory crepes, and soups. Reviewers note fresh ingredients and friendly staff. The location provides kerbside pickup, delivery, and takeaway options. Hours are 9 am to 8:30 pm, with Sundays closed.
Best for: Paninis, crepes, and coffee
- Address
- 8222 17th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11214, United States
- Hours
- Fri 9 am–8:30 pm; Mon 9 am–8:30 pm; Sat 9 am–8:30 pm; Sun Closed; Thu 9 am–8:30 pm; Tue 9 am–8:30 pm; Wed 9 am–8:30 pm
#4
Ortobello's
★ 4.6 (552 Google reviews)Italian restaurant
Representative photo, not of this business.
Ortobello's is a small, cozy spot known for huge family-style portions. Reviewers frequently recommend the chicken parm, mozzarella and peppers salad, and fillet capricicosa. The sauce is described as top-notch, with some dishes available off-menu upon request. Open from 4:30 pm to 10 pm on most days, with Mondays closed, it offers a homey feel despite a modest storefront.
Best for: Family-style chicken parm
- Address
- 6401 Bay Pkwy, Brooklyn, NY 11204, United States
- Hours
- Fri 4:30–10 pm; Mon Closed; Sat 4:30–10 pm; Sun 4–9 pm; Thu 4:30–10 pm; Tue 4:30–10 pm; Wed 4:30–10 pm
#5
Villa Fiorita
★ 4.7 (164 Google reviews)Italian restaurant
Representative photo, not of this business.
Villa Fiorita provides a warm, homey atmosphere with professional service. Reviewers highlight the chicken country style, stuffed mushrooms, and calamari as excellent choices. The food is described as tasting homemade, though some pasta dishes may need more seasoning. The venue has plenty of seating and wheelchair-accessible entrances and seating. Hours are 4 pm to 9 pm, with Mondays and Tuesdays closed.
Best for: Homemade Italian classics
- Address
- 7720 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11214, United States
- Hours
- Fri 4–9 pm; Mon Closed; Sat 4–9 pm; Sun 2–8 pm; Thu 4–9 pm; Tue Closed; Wed 4–9 pm
How we made this list
We looked at 7 restaurants in Bensonhurst, New York NY with a Google rating of 4.0 or higher and at least 20 reviews, then Google category “Italian restaurant”, ranked by weighted rating. A rating from thousands of reviews counts for more than the same rating from a handful, so a new place with a few perfect scores does not jump the queue. Ratings and hours are from public Google listings on 28 September 2026 and can change. Nobody paid to be on this list.
Tips before you go
- For an early start, Panino Rustico of Bensonhurst opens at 9 am.
- Hours and prices come from Google listings and change, so check the listing before a long trip.
Frequently asked questions
Which is the highest-rated restaurant on this list?
Mama Rao's ranks first, with a Google rating of 4.7 from 763 reviews. L&B Spumoni Gardens is second at 4.6 from 11,580 reviews.
Which restaurants in Bensonhurst, New York NY are open late?
None of these stays open past midnight. The latest to close is L&B Spumoni Gardens, at 11:30 pm.
How much does it cost at these restaurants?
Google lists these price ranges per person: Panino Rustico of Bensonhurst $10–20. The others do not list a price range.
Which of these have free parking?
Google lists free parking for Panino Rustico of Bensonhurst.
More guides for Bensonhurst
Run a business in Bensonhurst?
Get a fast website with your hours, menu, location and reviews. If your business is listed here and something is wrong, tell us and we fix it.
Email support@pagenearby.com