5 Underrated Bakeries in Downtown, Lexington KY Worth Trying

This guide covers bakeries in and around Downtown Lexington, KY that deserve more attention. Each one is rated 4.4 or higher on Google but has fewer than 400 reviews, so they are easy to overlook. We considered 12 qualifying businesses and ranked the top five by rating. It is useful if you want a custom cake, a pastry run or something different from the usual chains.

The list at a glance

  1. 1The Bourbon Bakery★ 5 · 24 reviews · $100+
  2. 2Al-Taj Bakery★ 4.9 · 317 reviews
  3. 3Selena's Cake Pops & More★ 4.9 · 102 reviews
  4. 4Tinker's Cake Shop★ 4.9 · 80 reviews
  5. 5Mondelli's Bake Shop★ 4.8 · 266 reviews · $1–10
#1

The Bourbon Bakery

★ 5 (24 Google reviews)Bakery and Cake Shop$100+ per person

Representative photo, not of this business.

The Bourbon Bakery is a special-order bakery rated 5 from 24 reviews, with pickup inside The Liberty Road Cafe on Henry Clay Blvd. Google lists delivery and in-store pickup. Reviewers mention muffins and cookies with rich flavor, including lower-sugar options, and a custom vanilla heart cake that matched a vintage design. Regulars point to hand-produced items made with high-quality ingredients. Hours are not listed, so order ahead.

Best for: Custom cakes and lower-sugar muffins
Address
Special Order Only. Pick Up inside The Liberty Road Cafe, 720 Henry Clay Blvd, Lexington, KY 40505, United States
Hours
hours not listed
#2

Al-Taj Bakery

★ 4.9 (317 Google reviews)Bakery and Cake Shop

Representative photo, not of this business.

Al-Taj Bakery on Nichols Park Dr is rated 4.9 from 317 reviews. It is open Tuesday to Saturday from 9:30 am to 7 pm, Sunday from 12 to 5 pm, and closed Monday. Reviewers mention Arab desserts, baklava, Turkish delights and savory pies, including meat pies and a cheese and muhammara pie. One visitor says they drive 90 minutes for it, and others say the owner offered samples. The entrance is wheelchair accessible.

Best for: Baklava and Middle Eastern savory pies
Address
4097 Nichols Park Dr, Lexington, KY 40503, United States
Hours
Fri 9:30 am–7 pm; Mon Closed; Sat 9:30 am–7 pm; Sun 12–5 pm; Thu 9:30 am–7 pm; Tue 9:30 am–7 pm; Wed 9:30 am–7 pm
#3

Selena's Cake Pops & More

★ 4.9 (102 Google reviews)Bakery and Cake Shop

Representative photo, not of this business.

Selena's Cake Pops & More is rated 4.9 from 102 reviews and is open Monday to Saturday from 9 am to 8 pm, closed Sunday. No street address is listed on Google. Reviewers mention wedding cakes, including a funfetti flavor, plus cupcakes and rice crispy treats. Regulars point to easy flavor selection, responsive communication, on-time delivery with setup help, and cake toppers made with a 3D printer.

Best for: Wedding cakes, cupcakes and cake pops
Address
Hours
Fri 9 am–8 pm; Mon 9 am–8 pm; Sat 9 am–8 pm; Sun Closed; Thu 9 am–8 pm; Tue 9 am–8 pm; Wed 9 am–8 pm
#4

Tinker's Cake Shop

★ 4.9 (80 Google reviews)Bakery and Cake Shop

Representative photo, not of this business.

Tinker's Cake Shop on W Maxwell St is rated 4.9 from 80 reviews. It is open Tuesday to Saturday from 10 am to 5 pm and closed Sunday and Monday. Reviewers mention wedding cakes, including a watercolor design and three-flavor tastings, along with a gluten-free chocolate cake and an almond raspberry cake. One reviewer notes a free first-anniversary recreation of a small top tier. Takeaway is listed.

Best for: Wedding cakes and gluten-free options
Address
317 W Maxwell St, Lexington, KY 40508, United States
Hours
Fri 10 am–5 pm; Mon Closed; Sat 10 am–5 pm; Sun Closed; Thu 10 am–5 pm; Tue 10 am–5 pm; Wed 10 am–5 pm
#5

Mondelli's Bake Shop

★ 4.8 (266 Google reviews)Bakery and Cake Shop$1–10 per person

Representative photo, not of this business.

Mondelli's Bake Shop on Pimlico Pkwy is rated 4.8 from 266 reviews. It is open Wednesday to Friday from 7 am to 5 pm, Saturday from 7 am to 3 pm and Sunday from 8 am to 12 pm, closed Monday and Tuesday. Reviewers mention birthday cakes, buttercream icing and a character-themed cake. One reviewer was disappointed with a recent custom order. Free parking and takeaway are listed.

Best for: Birthday cakes and weekend morning pastries
Address
3120 Pimlico Pkwy #162, Lexington, KY 40517, United States
Hours
Fri 7 am–5 pm; Mon Closed; Sat 7 am–3 pm; Sun 8 am–12 pm; Thu 7 am–5 pm; Tue Closed; Wed 7 am–5 pm

How we made this list

We looked at 12 bakeries in Downtown, Lexington KY with a Google rating of 4.0 or higher and at least 20 reviews, then rated 4.4 or higher on Google but with fewer than 400 reviews. A rating from thousands of reviews counts for more than the same rating from a handful, so a new place with a few perfect scores does not jump the queue. Ratings and hours are from public Google listings on 05 October 2026 and can change. Nobody paid to be on this list.

Tips before you go

Frequently asked questions

Which is the highest-rated bakery on this list?

The Bourbon Bakery ranks first, with a Google rating of 5 from 24 reviews. Al-Taj Bakery is second at 4.9 from 317 reviews.

Which bakeries in Downtown, Lexington KY are open late?

None of these stays open past midnight. The latest to close is Selena's Cake Pops & More, at 8 pm.

How much does it cost at these bakeries?

Google lists these price ranges per person: The Bourbon Bakery $100+; Mondelli's Bake Shop $1–10. The others do not list a price range.

Which of these have free parking?

Google lists free parking for Mondelli's Bake Shop.

More guides for Downtown

Run a business in Downtown?

Get a fast website with your hours, menu, location and reviews. If your business is listed here and something is wrong, tell us and we fix it.

Email support@pagenearby.com